Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street, nestled in the heart of Lexington, KY, where every slice tells a story. This vibrant eatery is not just about pizza; it's a celebration of rich flavors and community spirit. Locals rave about the New York-style pizza, characterized by its sweet sauce and perfectly thin crust, touted by customers like C D as reminiscent of the best pies from NJ/NY.
Must-try items include the fan-favorite habanero ranch dipping sauce, which elevates every bite. Plus, keep an eye out for the fantastic Monday promotion with 50% off 12-inch pizzas, perfect for budget-conscious diners. The staff here is not only friendly but also passionate about pizza, enhancing the cozy, welcoming environment.
- Location: 110 N Mill St, Lexington, KY 40507
- Contact: +1 859-281-1101
Whether you’re winding down after a night out or seeking a delicious meal, Goodfellas Pizzeria is your go-to spot for delightful pizza and good vibes!
Sides
Breadstick
A single breadstick that is literally the size of your arm. Covered in garlic butter, parmesan, and dusted with oregano. Served with your choice of sauce
Cheese Bread
Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.
Buff Chicken Cheese Bread
Need we say more? This snack is a tastebud pleaser! Served with housemade ranch
Pesto Bread
A New York Tribeca bread baguette, spread with a generous amount of housemade pesto, topped with mozzarella and baked till golden brown.
Sun Dried Tomato Bread
A New York Tribeca bread baguette brushed with garlic infused olive oil, topped with imported Italian sun dried tomatoes, cheese, and finished with fresh basil.
Meatballs
Our world class meatballs made of pork and beef are smothered in our house made marinara and topped with ricotta and basil... Mangia!*soy,milk,gluten,egg
Extra Sauce
Marinara, Ranch, Garlic Butter, Nacho Cheese, Buffalo Ranch
Al Pacino
An extra large meatball sub sandwich with our signature marinara sauce, on a toasted Tribeca bread baguette, and stuffed with the best meatballs you'll ever taste!
Subs
Calzones
Calzone
This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share!- toppings 2.00 each (limit 3)
12 Pie
Build your own 12 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way
12 Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 12 half pie all to yourself.
16 Pie
Build your own 16 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way
16 Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 16 half pie all to yourself.
22 Pie
Build your own 22 pizza like a Boss! Start with a plain cheese and make it like Sinatra... Your Way
22 Half & Half Pie
Can't come to an agreement with the family... Split it down the middle with a 22 half pie all to yourself.
Pizza
Salads
Caprese Salad
A simple salad made of fresh Fior di Latte mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, then drizzled with olive oil and seasoned
Spring Mix Salad
A small side salad with fresh spring mix, red onions, tomatoes, and sliced button mushrooms.
Pasta Salad
A tri-colored rotini pasta salad tossed with diced roma tomatoes, banana peppers, black olives, red onion, and broccoli. Finished with housemade Italian dressing.
Cannoli
A housemade Italian pastry filled with sweet ricotta and chocolate chips
Chocolate Chip Cookie
An extra large staple cookie with extra chocolate
Black and White Cookie
Seinfeld's favorite... a New York staple
Cheesecake
Hands down the best you've ever had!
Desserts
Beverages
Bottled Water
Goodfellas very own bottled spring water
Soda
Coca-cola products in a reusable Goodfellas stadium cup