Welcome to Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street, located at 110 N Mill St in Lexington, KY, is a must-visit destination for pizza lovers. Renowned for its exceptional New York-style pizza, the pizzeria combines quality ingredients with a vibrant atmosphere. Patrons rave about the sweet sauce, perfectly crispy crust, and the option to customize their slices to perfection. The friendly staff enhances the experience, creating a welcoming environment that keeps customers returning. Whether you’re enjoying a late-night slice after a night out or grabbing a meal on the go, Goodfellas offers delicious, affordable options that elevate the local dining scene.
-
110 N Mill St, Lexington, KY 40507, United States Hotline: +1 859-281-1101
Welcome to Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Lexington, Kentucky. Located at 110 N Mill St, this spot offers an enticing slice of New York-style pizza that has local food enthusiasts buzzing. When you cross the threshold of Goodfellas, you're not just stepping into a pizzeria; you're entering a vibrant space filled with the warmth of delicious aromas and the inviting chatter of satisfied customers.
The brand's reputation as a go-to pizza destination is echoed by numerous patrons who rave about its delectable offerings. One satisfied customer, Johnny Lancaster, proclaims it his "go-to pizza place," emphasizing that the pizza is consistently great and never disappoints. This sentiment is echoed throughout the reviews, where fans like C D share their joy over the expertly crafted slices, boasting sweet sauce and perfectly balanced grease — memories reminiscent of the classic East Coast pizzerias they hold dear.
Speaking of the pizza, the standout experience is not just in the dough or the toppings, but also in the creative additions like the habanero ranch dip, which Elizabeth Wilkins insists you must try. And let’s not forget the magical Mondays, when you can snag half-off 12-inch pizzas, making the experience not only delicious but also friendly to your wallet!
For those who appreciate a little personal touch, the staff at Goodfellas is noted for their friendliness and attentiveness. As Scott Perrine describes, the service is personable, enhancing the communal vibe of the pizzeria. And diners will find the environment just as enjoyable, with its lively atmosphere perfect for unwinding after a night on the town.
In conclusion, Goodfellas Pizzeria - Mill Street is more than just a pizza place. It's a haven for pizza lovers where affordability meets flavor, creating a remarkable experience worthy of its loyal following. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this pizzeria promises not only a meal but a slice of happiness. So, grab a seat, order up a large slice, and dive into what could easily become your new favorite pizza destination in Lexington!
Goodfellas Pizzeria is as badass as its namesake. Great pizza and awesome staff. It's a must eat and don't forget to order habanero ranch to dip!
My soul is jumping from happiness. I lived in NJ/NY for 21 years and am very accustomed to their pizza. I bought a slice to try before buying a pie and it was *everything* I could ever want. Sweet sauce, perfect amount of grease, thin, awesome size, good crust, and made in a snazzy environment. Big recommend!!!
Businesses should not suffer due to the disruptive behavior of patrons. They have a right to remove them regardless of whether or not they support the business, There are rules when you step onto someone else's property. follow the rules enjoy the pizza or get out.
My go to pizza place in Lexington!!! The pizza is ALWAYS great and never disappoints!!! Go get you a slice of NY in the KY!!!
I bought a baby crib from one of the upper management from Good Fellows . First time i ever heard of the place last week. This week, I heard of this pizzaria from Candice Owens. She mentioned how some uppity entited Pilthydephia jew caused a scene at Good Fellows Pizzaria. I can't wait to get back home so I can take my family and friends out to my hometown local pizzeria in Lexington, Kentucky. Must be a God send since i never heard of Good Fellows before and then to hear of it on different wave lengths?
The pizza is great. Don't miss Monday half off 12 inch pizzas. My only negative which is very minor, the garlic butter is too salty. The service was great the staff was very personable and nice.
Great place! 10.61 for a large slice, 2 foot long breadstick and cheese or red sauce and a drink meal! All you can grab Parmesan and pepper packets! Tips and tricks: ask them to get your slice well done. They will put it back in the oven for 30 seconds and it’s so good!
My FAVORITE pizza spot EVER!!! Affordable, delicious, vibe is on point. The perfect hidden lil gem located in the of downtown. Plus, they're open super late so after a night enjoying Lex night life, stop in and enjoy a slice of heaven.